Welcome to this week’s Aitken Robertson Win of the Week. In this series we highlight recent great results from our lawyers and paralegals, including wins at trial and withdrawals of charges.
This week’s win comes from our lawyer, Tarinpal Dhaliwal, who obtained a resolution for our client who was charged with domestic assault and failure to appear in court. Our client and his ex-girlfriend, the complainant, were at his residence sharing a few drinks when an argument ensued over the whereabouts of the complainant’s cell phone. Allegedly, our client grabbed his ex-girlfriend by the arms and forced her out of the apartment leaving bruises on her arms. The complainant’s father later contacted the police to report the assault. A few weeks prior to this incident, the complainant and her mother assaulted our client by punching him in the face. However, he decided that he did not want to speak to police or to press charges.
The police later reached out to our client at two o’clock in the morning. The police claim that he refused to share his location and would not turn himself in. It was not until he was stopped at a traffic stop that he was arrested for the outstanding warrant as well as another warrant for domestic assault after a second incident occurred in another jurisdiction. After he had been arrested, the complainant returned to the police station to recant her statement and say that nothing had happened despite telling her father that our client had assaulted her.
Mr. Dhaliwal worked closely with our client throughout the entire process. The Crown touched on an overall lack of evidence for the case, i.e., no text messages, photographs, or notes from medical staff. Initially, if our client completed counselling, the matter was being screened for a peace bond. During this counselling, our client’s support worker stated that he would not require a more intensive mental health case management and that he was successful in reflecting on his behaviour and addressing any changes that he would need to make in his life. After our client had completed counselling as well as a Partner Assault Response program, Mr. Dhaliwal met with the Crown and requested that the matter be resolved by way of the peace bond, and the charges were dismissed. Additionally, the domestic assault charge from the other jurisdiction was also solved by way of a peace bond. These were two very successful outcomes for our client who was able to put this unfortunate incident behind him while also addressing mental health challenges that he was facing that potentially led to the incident.

