CASE DETAILS
LEARN MORE →The Background
Our client, Ms. C, was charged with impaired operation following a motor vehicle stop initiated by police in response to a 911 call, contrary to section 320.14(1)(b) of the Criminal Code of Canada. The call did not report impaired driving, unsafe vehicle operation, or any Highway Traffic Act concerns; officers simply responded to a “suspicious vehicle” call, absent any lawful basis for detention. Police nonetheless stopped Ms. C’s vehicle shortly after observing it leave the area referenced in the call. At the time of the stop, police had not observed any driving behaviour suggesting impairment or a traffic offence. Ms. C complied with police requests and was cooperative throughout the interaction. During the stop, officers observed an open container of alcohol inside the vehicle, which led to an Approved Screening Device (ASD) demand, an arrest, and the collection of breath samples, which ultimately formed the basis of the Crown’s case. Mr. Dhaliwal’s position was that the police lacked lawful authority to stop and detain Ms. C in the first place, rendering all evidence obtained thereafter the product of a charter violation.
The Goals
The primary goal of Mr. Dhaliwal was to ensure that Ms. C’s constitutional rights were fully protected and that the Court closely examined the legality of the police conduct leading to her detention and arrest. Mr. Dhaliwal sought a complete acquittal by demonstrating that Ms. C had been arbitrarily detained in breach of section 9 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The defence objective was to exclude the evidence obtained as a direct result of the unlawful detention, rather than to pursue a negotiated resolution or a reduced outcome.
The Strategy
Mr. Dhaliwal presented a detailed Charter application grounded in section 9 of the Charter, which protects individuals from arbitrary detention. He emphasized that a lawful vehicle stop must be authorized by law and carried out in a reasonable manner. He demonstrated that the 911 call relied upon by police had no connection to impaired driving or traffic safety. In the absence of any Highway Traffic Act justification, police could only lawfully stop Ms. C’s vehicle if there existed reasonable suspicion of some other offence. Mr. Dhaliwal argued that no such reasonable suspicion was present at the time of the stop.
Mr. Dhaliwal established that the detention was not authorized by law. The Court ultimately found that, in the absence of any highway traffic concerns, the police lacked lawful authority to stop Ms. C’s vehicle. Mr. Dhaliwal then argued that the evidence obtained following the unlawful detention flowed directly from the Charter breach and should be excluded.
The Results
Through the dedicated efforts of Mr. Dhaliwal, the Court agreed with the defence presented and found that Ms. C had been arbitrarily detained in violation of section 9 of the Charter. As a result, the evidence obtained during and following the unlawful detention was excluded. With the Crown’s case rendered untenable, Ms. C was acquitted of all charges. Mr. Dhaliwal secured a complete acquittal for his client and reinforced the fundamental protections afforded to all individuals under the Charter. Overall, Ms. C expressed her sincere appreciation for Mr. Dhaliwal’s thorough expertise, his professional guidance throughout the legal process, and the successful result he was ultimately able to secure.
FREE CONSULTATION
Please note that the submission of this form does not mean that we are your retained lawyer. This is a form establishing preliminary information regarding the scheduling of a free, 30-minute consultation. Any personal information collected through means such as consultation forms will not be conveyed or shared except to the extent necessary to properly represent you and your case. Aitken Robertson will never sell any personal information. We value your privacy.
SMS Disclosure: By providing a telephone number for SMS/Text purposes and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging.
