Skip to content


Charge(s): Domestic Assault
Location: Windsor
Our Client(s): Ms. J
Year: 2023
Lawyer/Paralegal: Sudine Riley
Sudine Riley - Criminal LawyerLEARN MORE

Please Note: Past results not predictive of future results.

The Background

Ms. J, a 20 year-old woman, found herself embroiled in a legal dispute when she was charged with domestic assault. The altercation involved her husband, who was also charged in the incident. The charges cast a shadow over Ms. J’s reputation and threatened her freedom and immigration status.

Case Overview: The charges stemmed from a reported altercation between Ms. J and her husband in a parking lot. An eyewitness, whose account formed the basis of the prosecution’s case, called the police to report the fight. The eyewitness claimed to have witnessed Ms. J engaging in aggressive behaviour towards her husband.

The Goals

Ms. J sought legal representation to challenge the allegations against her.

The Strategy

Her defence attorney devised a strategy focused on undermining the reliability of eyewitness testimony. Eyewitness accounts, while often persuasive, can be subject to biases, inaccuracies, and misinterpretations.

Execution of the Defence: We meticulously scrutinized the eyewitness testimony and identified key inconsistencies and potential biases. Drawing upon a wealth of research and legal precedent, the defence meticulously unraveled the weaknesses inherent in eyewitness testimony. From the fallibility of human memory to the influence of environmental factors, every facet of the eyewitness account was scrutinized with precision. What emerged was a nuanced understanding of the complexities involved in relying solely on eyewitness testimony to substantiate criminal charges.

 By highlighting inconsistencies, discrepancies, and potential biases in the witness’s perception, the defence effectively undermined the prosecution’s case. The passerby’s recollection of events, once seen as irrefutable evidence, now stood on shaky ground—a house of cards destined to crumble under the weight of scrutiny.

Challenges Faced: Challenging eyewitness evidence presented a significant hurdle in our client’s case. The prosecution initially relied heavily on the eyewitness’s version of events, considering it pivotal in establishing Ms. J’s guilt. Overcoming the presumption of credibility attached to eyewitness testimony required a comprehensive and compelling defence strategy.

The Results

Through persistent advocacy and a meticulous dismantling of the eyewitness evidence, we succeeded in casting doubt on the reliability of the prosecution’s case. Recognizing the weaknesses in the eyewitness testimony and the potential for reasonable doubt, the Crown ultimately chose to withdraw the charges against our client.

Ms. J’s case underscores the importance of scrutinizing eyewitness evidence in criminal proceedings. By challenging the reliability of the eyewitness account, we achieved a favourable outcome, sparing her from the consequences of unjust accusations and severe immigration implications. The successful defence highlights the critical role of thorough investigation, strategic legal advocacy in safeguarding the rights of the accused and upholding the principles of justice.


Tell us a bit about yourself and the situation.  Completing this form helps us book your free consultation with the most appropriate lawyer at our firm and at a time that is most convenient to you.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Let's start with the basics. What is your name?
More information on our privacy policy can be read here: Privacy Policy.

Please note that the submission of this form does not mean that we are your retained lawyer. This is a form establishing preliminary information regarding the scheduling of a free, 30-minute consultation. Any personal information collected through means such as consultation forms will not be conveyed or shared except to the extent necessary to properly represent you and your case. Aitken Robertson will never sell any personal information. We value your privacy.

SMS Disclosure: By providing a telephone number for SMS/Text purposes and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging.

Back To Top