
Although dangerous driving is not an impaired charge, due to readers’ requests, we have added this informative chapter to our book.
Range of Driving Offences
There is a range of driving offences, starting from minor regulatory breaches to severe criminal charges like vehicular manslaughter. Minor offences, like speeding or not wearing a seatbelt, are called regulatory offences. These don’t require intent; just doing the act is enough for guilt and punishment. Next are specific liability offences, like careless driving or stunt driving, with heavier penalties. To avoid conviction, you need to prove you took reasonable care. These offences carry heavier penalties and often can result in jail in the most serious cases.
The fact that you have committed the act creates a burden on you to show that you used due diligence to avoid committing the offence. For example, when you are forced to exceed the speed limit by more than 50 km/h because of another unsafe driver, you may not be guilty of stunt driving but only of speeding.
Dangerous Driving Can Lead to Jail Time
Dangerous driving is more serious, leading to jail time and lengthy license suspensions. It’s about actions that hugely deviate from expected driving standards. The test to determine if someone is driving dangerously is whether their actions are a “marked departure” from the usual standard expected from drivers. This is more than any departure, i.e. just speeding or similar, but must be a marked noticeable or remarkable change. The question of the usual standard expected of “normal” drivers is often where the most significant arguments in law come down.
Criminal Negligence
The further level beyond dangerous driving is criminal negligence. Criminal negligence is even more severe, requiring a marked and substantial departure from the ordinary care that drivers use. This requires significant, noticeable or exceptional differences from normal driving. Again, what is “normal” becomes a live issue, and where these blurred lines between “marked departure” and “marked and substantial departure” meet is rarely straightforward.
Intentional Harm
The highest level of culpability is intentional harm caused by driving, which can lead to assault, assault, assault with a weapon up to manslaughter where someone is killed or murdered if it is an intentional killing.
These offences blur together. The impact of a criminal record, the insurance consequences, and, especially if someone gets hurt, the civil consequences can all be significant. Thus, having someone skilled in explaining why a lesser charge fits better to the judge, the jury or the Crown attorney can be crucial.
Different driving behaviours fall on a spectrum from minor to major offences. Small infractions, like speeding, can lead to more serious charges like dangerous driving. These charges overlap, and managing them requires expertise. Ensuring that the right charge is put before the Court is essential as it will significantly affect sentencing. Different small matters can add up to a more significant charge. Knocking out some of those smaller matters can often undermine the case against you. Speed plus brief inattention (texting) plus passing might equal dangerous driving, but getting rid of the texting matter might mean a much lesser charge or even an acquittal. Sometimes, the prosecution will aim for larger charges but, in doing so, will lose the whole case because they ignored the more minor charges that make up the course of conduct that would lead to a conviction.
Dealing with Multiple Charges that include Dangerous Driving
Multiple charge problems arise where a dangerous driving charge is laid along with other charges. Unlike a drinking and driving offence, which may allow you to drive in as little as three months with a blower device installed, a dangerous driving charge will result in at least a one-year driver’s licence suspension in Ontario. Dangerous driving does not carry a mandatory driving prohibition from the criminal courts but does carry a mandatory suspension by the Ministry of Transportation in Ontario.
Getting a driver’s licence from a different jurisdiction may help solve this problem, as not all provinces impose mandatory suspensions for dangerous driving convictions. In Ontario, increased suspensions for multiple convictions apply to those for drinking and driving offences but also for many other charges like dangerous driving or criminal negligence involving a car.
Impaired Driving with Dangerous Driving Charges
It is possible to be convicted of both impaired driving and dangerous driving. If you are, the additional driving suspension from the dangerous driving charge will prevent you from enrolling in Stream A and getting your driver’s licence back sooner.
Although the longer driving suspensions arguably now make dangerous driving more serious than impaired driving for consequences, they have one advantage. It is possible (unlike with a DUI) to get a conditional discharge and no criminal record with a plea to dangerous driving. This non-criminality can be an important consideration for non-Canadians who would otherwise risk deportation and or difficulties with their legal status, permanent residency and citizenship applications. Sometimes, in these circumstances, clients choose (if the Crown makes the option available) to plead to dangerous driving instead of impaired driving.
