Introduction to DUI and Immigration Issues
On December 18, 2018, significant amendments were made to the Criminal Code of Canada concerning drinking and driving offences, including Impaired Driving, Exceed 80, and Fail/Refuse to provide a breath sample in Ontario, raising concerns among Temporary Residents and Permanent Residents in Canada. A significant change brought about by the amendments is the increase in the maximum possible term of imprisonment for a DUI offence proceeding by indictment. Previously, the maximum sentence was capped at five years. However, currently, it stands at ten years. Furthermore, if the DUI offence involves bodily harm or death, the new maximum penalties, when the Crown proceeds by indictment, are 14 years imprisonment and life imprisonment, respectively.
The Amendments
These amendments have elevated DUI offences to what the immigration legislation terms as offences of “serious criminality.” These changes have severe immigration-related consequences for individuals convicted of drinking and driving offences. The amendments increase the maximum possible term of imprisonment for DUI offences, categorizing them as “serious criminality” under the Immigration Regulation Protection Act (“IRPA”). A Temporary Resident or a Permanent Resident is inadmissible to Canada for a serious criminality offence. Inadmissibility can possibly lead to deportation from Canada.
The amendment impacts both Permanent and Temporary residents (“foreign nationals”), jeopardizing their status and leading to potential removal proceedings under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) upon a DUI conviction. The interaction between the Criminal Code and the IRPA emphasizes the gravity of these changes, making DUI offences a significant consideration for individuals residing in Canada.
The connection between DUI convictions and immigration status is crucial, as even a single conviction can result in inadmissibility to Canada, impacting a Permanent Resident or Temporary Resident’s ability to enter or remain in Canada. The enactment of new laws has significantly affected individuals seeking entry into Canada for various purposes, emphasizing the need for understanding the legal consequences of such offences.
The recent amendments have also impacted the concept of Deemed Rehabilitation, making individuals convicted of impaired driving offences after December 18, 2018, ineligible for this status. The discretionary role of immigration officers in assessing admissibility and the potential consequences highlighted by the Immigration Minister underscores the importance of caution and compliance with the law. Protective measures are outlined by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) to safeguard the status of Permanent Residents and Foreign Nationals facing DUI convictions. It is essential for individuals to prioritize safety, responsible behaviour, and compliance with the law to maintain their immigration status and contribute to a safe society in Canada.
Repercussions on Immigration Status Due to Criminal Convictions
This chart serves as a reference only and should not substitute for legal counsel.
The amendment impacts both Permanent and Temporary residents (“foreign nationals”), jeopardizing their status and leading to potential removal proceedings under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) upon a DUI conviction. The interaction between the Criminal Code and the IRPA emphasizes the gravity of these changes, making DUI offences a significant consideration for individuals residing in Canada.
The connection between DUI convictions and immigration status is crucial, as even a single conviction can result in inadmissibility to Canada, impacting a Permanent Resident or Temporary Resident’s ability to enter or remain in Canada. The enactment of new laws has significantly affected individuals seeking entry into Canada for various purposes, emphasizing the need for understanding the legal consequences of such offences.
The recent amendments have also impacted the concept of Deemed Rehabilitation, making individuals convicted of impaired driving offences after December 18, 2018, ineligible for this status. The discretionary role of immigration officers in assessing admissibility and the potential consequences highlighted by the Immigration Minister underscores the importance of caution and compliance with the law. Protective measures are outlined by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) to safeguard the status of Permanent Residents and Foreign Nationals facing DUI convictions. It is essential for individuals to prioritize safety, responsible behaviour, and compliance with the law to maintain their immigration status and contribute to a safe society in Canada.
Impact of Conviction Date on Categorization
The timing of an impaired driving conviction plays a crucial role in determining its classification under the IRPA. Following the implementation of the new DUI laws, individuals convicted of impaired driving offences on or after December 18, 2018, face heightened scrutiny and the potential classification under the “serious criminality” threshold. In contrast, DUI convictions occurring before this significant date are classified under the lower tier of “criminality” within the IRPA framework.
Consequently, the penalties and consequences from the revised DUI laws do not extend to offences committed before December 18, 2018.
Transitional Arrangements
An essential consideration is the difference between the offence’s commission and the conviction date. If an individual commits a drinking and driving offence before December 18, 2018, but the sentencing occurs after this date, the previous DUI laws continue to apply to the case. It is crucial to note that only offences that take place on or after December 18, 2018, trigger the application of the updated DUI legislation.
Appealing Inadmissibility: Limited Options
Under section 64(1) of the IRPA, individuals considered inadmissible to Canada due to serious criminality, such as foreign nationals, permanent residents, and temporary residents, do not have the right to appeal this determination to the Immigration and Appeal Division. With impaired driving offences now classified as serious criminality, avenues for appealing inadmissibility based on these grounds have been effectively closed off. However, individuals facing inadmissibility can explore alternative avenues, such as humanitarian and compassionate grounds, with the guidance of legal advisors or judicial reviews. While these appeals are challenging, given the legislative intent behind the stringent DUI laws, seeking legal counsel can offer clarity on available options.
Mitigating Inadmissibility: Legal Approaches
Under these recent laws, Permanent or Temporary Residents face dire consequences, including those who have invested considerable time and effort into obtaining their status. A Permanent Resident convicted of DUI offences risk losing their status and facing deportation, regardless of whether the offence occurred in Canada or abroad. Even for first-time offenders with minor penalties, such as a $1,000 fine and a 12-month driving prohibition, the designation of “serious criminality” applies uniformly, neglecting individual circumstances.
In certain scenarios, individuals may explore legal pathways to mitigate the repercussions of DUI convictions. We at Aitken Robertson have a successful track record in negotiating alternate resolutions/plea agreements with the Crown that do not impact the immigration status of a Permanent or Temporary Resident. For example – a conditional or absolute discharges for offences like dangerous driving can prevent individuals from becoming inadmissible. While this strategy can help alleviate concerns related to criminal inadmissibility, it is essential to understand the specific implications of various plea agreements, especially regarding the use of Ignition Interlock devices.

