Skip to content

What is a Crown Pre-Trial?

From 17 Secrets to Helping You Survive (and Win) Your DUI Charges

17 Secrets to Helping You Survive (and Win) Your DUI Charge
pre-trial meeting

After you have reviewed the disclosure from the Crown, the next step will be for your lawyer and the Crown to have an informal discussion about your case. This is called a Crown pretrial, and the only people present will be the defence lawyer and the Crown.

At a Crown pre-trial, your lawyer and the Crown will discuss a variety of matters, whether it be in preparation for a trial or with the intention of resolving the case without a trial. Both the Crown and your lawyer will present their positions on the case in terms of what outcome they may seek and what arguments they may make. Sometimes, your lawyer will be able to reach a resolution with the Crown for a withdrawal of the charges or an otherwise less harsh form of penalty. This would be a beneficial outcome in terms of the result as well as in terms of legal fees, time, and stress involved in the case as a whole.

If you made any notes of evidence that is missing from the disclosure review that the Crown may be able to provide, the Crown pre-trial is an opportunity to request this material. This is also a chance to make a request for any necessary changes to the conditions of the undertaking or release order: recall that the Crown’s approval is required in order for changes to these conditions to be made.

In many cases, a key goal of the Crown pre-trial is to negotiate a plea deal. A plea deal is an agreement between the accused and the Crown, whereby the Crown agrees to seek a more lenient sentence or a non-criminal disposition in exchange for a guilty plea from the accused to the charge, or sometimes to a less serious charge. For example, your lawyer may be able to negotiate an offer with the Crown where you plead guilty to a lesser criminal charge, and the Crown agrees not to seek jail time.

Of course, your lawyer will never make any deal on your behalf unless you instruct them to do so. However, plea deals do have many advantages. For many, it is a desirable outcome to avoid going to a trial. Trials can be unpredictable in their outcomes, and as much as one can be confident in their own case going into a trial, there is always a possibility of a conviction and of an unpredictable sentence. With a plea deal, you have greater certainty that you get a penalty that you can manage and accept without the unpredictability of a trial. A plea deal also ensures that you do not have to incur the costs of a trial.

Agreeing to a Plea Deal

After agreeing to a plea deal, your lawyer and the Crown may make a joint submission to the court regarding a proposed sentence in accordance with the agreement reached during the Crown pre-trial. This signals to the court that both sides agree on the sentence to be imposed. Generally, as long as the proposed sentence is not completely contrary to the principles of sentencing outlined in the Criminal Code, the judge will likely agree with the joint submission. It is important to note, though, that the final decision rests with the judge and that they could impose a different sentence if they see it as necessary.

For some, it may be even more important to avoid a “guilty” verdict than to avoid a trial. Of course, you also should not plead guilty to something you did not do. While plea deals can therefore be a good outcome for those potentially anticipating a conviction, they may not be the goal for everyone.
In some cases, during a Crown pre-trial, your lawyer may be able to convince the Crown to withdraw the criminal charges entirely. This may happen if your lawyer is able to make a strong argument that the Crown does not have a reasonable chance of winning at trial with the evidence that they have. This would be an excellent outcome for any client, regardless of the goal: a withdrawal of the charges would save the time and cost of a trial while allowing the accused to walk free without a sexual assault conviction.

Other issues that could be addressed at a Crown pre-trial include matters in preparation for the trial, such as how long the trial should be expected to take and which witnesses could be called. If your lawyer and the Crown on their own are unable to come to a resolution that both sides can agree on, the next step is to attempt similar negotiations with a judge present. A judge may provide insight into which legal arguments are strong in the case at hand, and this can be helpful in facilitating an agreement.

Want Your Own Copy of This Book?
Download a Portable Version of This Book.
Download e-Book

FREE CONSULTATION

Tell us a bit about yourself and the situation.  Completing this form helps us book your free consultation with the most appropriate lawyer at our firm and at a time that is most convenient to you.
Let's start with the basics. What is your name?
Acknowledgement
More information on our privacy policy can be read here: Privacy Policy. More information on our terms of service can be read here: Terms of Service.

Please note that the submission of this form does not mean that we are your retained lawyer. This is a form establishing preliminary information regarding the scheduling of a free, 30-minute consultation. Any personal information collected through means such as consultation forms will not be conveyed or shared except to the extent necessary to properly represent you and your case. Aitken Robertson will never sell any personal information. We value your privacy.

SMS Disclosure: By providing a telephone number for SMS/Text purposes and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging.

Back To Top